Skip to main content

Highland Lake NY Real Estate & Homes for Rent

The median home value in Highland Lake, NY is $167,000. This is lower than the county median home value of $190,000. The national median home value is $308,980. The average price of homes sold in Highland Lake, NY is $167,000. Approximately 44.8% of Highland Lake homes are owned, compared to 12.8% rented, while 42.2% are vacant. Highland Lake real estate listings include condos, townhomes, and single family homes for sale. Commercial properties are also available. If you like to see a property, contact Highland Lake real estate agent to arrange a tour today!
Learn more about Highland Lake.


Showing Homes Nearby Highland Lake, NY
Beds:
3
Baths:
1.50
Sq.Ft.:
924
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6281426
Type:
Single Family, Ranch, Mobile Home
Lot size:
0.23 Acres
Year built:
1987
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Century 21 Geba Realty, (845) 856-6629
View additional info

Possible three bedroom, one bath, living room, dining room, kitchen, playroom, washer and dryer, closed porch, pond view. Available for sale as well. Owner is requiring 700+ credit score

Beds:
3
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
828
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6279108
Type:
Single Family, Ranch
Lot size:
5 Acres
Year built:
1948
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Hudson Valley, (917) 892-0749
View additional info

Welcome to Brook House! Experience the charm of a bygone era with all the modern comforts in this newly renovated 1940's cabin nestled in the serene woods. Boasting 3 cozy bedrooms, 1 bath, and a spacious deck perfect for relaxation and entertaining, this cabin is a haven for nature enthusiasts. View and listen to the soothing sounds of the babbling brook as you unwind in this tranquil 5-acre retreat. Located just a stone's throw away from Narrowsburg and the scenic Delaware River, this cabin offers the ideal blend of seclusion and convenience. Embrace the rustic elegance of yesteryears and make cherished memories in this timeless gem.

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
514
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6292782
Type:
Single Family, Ranch
Lot size:
5.7 Acres
Year built:
2024
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Lazy Meadows Realty, (917) 838-5342
View additional info

Brand new and Awesome and hard to find top notch rental. May be small but perfect for someone. 1 large studio room and a bathroom. Big deck and big property add to this rental's allure. Come on in, prop your feet up, and get upstate livin'. 5 minutes to Narrowsburg and the Delaware River. Security, 1st month and last month. 6 month lease minimum. Dogs considered with extra deposit and weight restrictions.

Beds:
1
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
625
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6293545
Type:
Single Family, Ranch
Subdivision:
Smallwood
Lot size:
0.17 Acres
Year built:
1935
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Woodstock Way Realty LLC, (845) 250-4200
View additional info

Sweet Catskills cottage provides a cozy summer retreat. Furnished 1BR seasonal Cabin, w/ country kitchen, bath w/shower is available Memorial Day thru Labor Day for $5400. extension possible. Enjoy an awesome serene enclosed porch + screen room, den w/propane "parlor stove" for cooler times, plus an amazing outdoor hot water shower! Peaceful country setting near hiking at the Forest Reserve + waterfall. Toronto Reservoir is down the road for swimming, fishing (need license) & boating. Bring your kayak. Short drive to Lake Superior State Park for swimming beach. White Lake/ Kauneonga Lake restaurants, Bethel Woods Center for the Arts +casino nearby. Please bring your own bedding incl pillows, towels & can also bring your own favorite cookware, window AC & smart TV. Owner pays utilities & internet. Parking for 1 car. Tenant responsible for trash removal. NO washer dryer. Can join The Club at Small wood for swimming and entertainment. check with them for fee. No smoking or vaping of any kind. No pets.

Beds:
1
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
600
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6298001
Type:
Apartment
Lot size:
1.2 Acres
Year built:
1930
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Hudson Valley, (845) 401-2540
View additional info

Spacious one-bedroom apartment on second floor located in a large multi-family home with its own separate entrance. You will find a large closet and some storage space. Plenty of natural light coming through the windows. It includes heat!! Parking is in front of building. Located just 5 miles from Port Jervis.

Beds:
2
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
900
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6286886
Type:
Apartment
Lot size:
3.46 Acres
Year built:
1951
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Resort Realty, (845) 655-9585
View additional info

2 Bed 1 Bath apartment in Monticello, NY. Close to schools, shopping, and restaurants. Please call and schedule your showing today! This unit will not last!

Beds:
3
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,660
Status:
NEW LISTING
MLS#:
H6295874
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
136.95 Acres
Year built:
1939
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Hudson Valley, (917) 892-0749
View additional info

Tucked away on a breathtaking 137-acre expanse, this exceptional 1,660 square foot home offers an ideal retreat for those seeking solitude and the allure of nature. Built in 1939 and meticulously updated to blend rustic charm with modern amenities, this two-story farmhouse is a sanctuary of comfort and style. The residence boasts three spacious bedrooms and three full bathrooms, including two ensuite, ensuring privacy and convenience for all occupants. The heart of this home is the cozy living room, highlighted by a classic wood stove that provides warmth and a nostalgic ambiance. The house has been thoughtfully renovated to meet contemporary standards while retaining its historic charm, making it an impeccable blend of old and new. For relaxation, step into the traditional wood-burning sauna, complete with a cold plunge feature, perfect for rejuvenating after a long day of hiking or riding ATVs on the extensive private trails that crisscross the property. Outside, the home features a welcoming front porch where you can enjoy the quiet mornings and a spacious back deck equipped with a BBQ setup, ideal for entertaining guests or enjoying peaceful evenings under the stars. Located just minutes from the charming hamlet of Narrowsburg and the scenic Delaware River, this home provides easy access to local shops, dining, and entertainment while maintaining a sense of seclusion and privacy. Whether you're looking for a peaceful retreat to unwind or a vibrant setting to explore the outdoors, this remarkable home offers the perfect blend of seclusion, comfort, and accessibility. Make this your new haven for experiencing life surrounded by nature in one of the most coveted areas near the Delaware River.

Beds:
3
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,100
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6302147
Type:
Ranch
Lot size:
2.2 Acres
Year built:
1960
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Joy Romano Realty, 845-701-9711
View additional info

Charming 3-Bedroom in Serene Cochecton, NY offers a perfect blend of comfort and privacy. Features three cozy bedrooms (wood floors), a large eat-in kitchen, a living room, dining room, and a full bathroom, complete with a convenient washer and dryer. Enjoy the fresh air and peaceful surroundings from the comfort of your own porch an ideal spot for morning coffee or evening relaxation. This is a duplex but has privacy the way it is situated. Central air conditioning. Sullivan West School District. Good credit, referrals and steady income are required. 1st months rent, 1 month securtiy and a half months broker fee due at lease signing. (agents see agent remarks).

Beds:
3
Baths:
1.50
Sq.Ft.:
2,200
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6283983
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.34 Acres
Year built:
1960
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Capital Estate Realty LLC, (347) 678-9851
View additional info
Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,700
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6282129
Type:
Single Family
Subdivision:
Ccpoa Aka: White Lake Ho
Year built:
1967
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Town & Country Preferred Prop, (845) 583-7700
View additional info

* LOCATION! LOCATION! LOCATION! * RARE opportunity to enjoy a DIRECT LAKEFRONT Home in the well-established & coveted White Lake Homes aka: CCPOA* This 4-BR / 3-BA home w/ a Large, deck overlooks White Lake, the spacious, Lakefront, Level Yard & WELCOMED SUNRISES * The Garden-Level, includes the 4th BR, 3rd BA, Stone-Patio, overlooking the Large, Private, Level & Well Maintained Yard that extends to the PRIVATE DOCK * The Dock facilitates slips for a Motor-Boat, Pontoon-Boat, Sail-Boat & Wave-Runner * This Home is a "Membership in the HOA is available upon payment of Dues * Membership is Voluntary & includes Clubhouse, Entertainment, Pool, Catered Parties, Playground, Sport-Courts & Year-round, Trash Collection * The Community boasts a Municipal, Sewer-System & Community Water-System * The home is located, several minutes; 1/2 Mi. to Lakefront, Dining, USPO, Music in the Park & the Gourmet Ice Cream Parlor * Application +Credit Report & Full Screening * "The early bird..." GOING......

Beds:
2
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
950
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6286969
Type:
Apartment
Lot size:
13.9 Acres
Year built:
1931
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Homes By Yara Realty Group LLC, (914) 841-8822
View additional info

Very nice second floor renovated unit. New floors, windows, freshly painted, good size rooms, has laundry hook ups. Beautiful area, river for tenant enjoyment across the river, perfect for nature lovers. plenty of parking. Tenant's please fill out application on the listing. Tenant responsible for first month rent, 1 month security and 1 month to landlord towards realty fee. No dogs allowed, but will consider a cat.

Beds:
3
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,400
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6282141
Type:
Apartment
Lot size:
13.9 Acres
Year built:
1931
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Homes By Yara Realty Group LLC, (914) 841-8822
View additional info

Located in Deerpark Orange county, not long island...beautiful area...very country, river across the street to be enjoyed for fishing, swimming picnicking...nature lovers will love living here. Located 20 minutes to Middletown, 15 to Port Jervis or Monticello. 3 Bedroom renovated apartment feels more like a single family home because it does not have anyone above you. Consist of master bedroom on main level and 2 bedrooms on second. large kitchen, big enough to be eat in and the living room is big enough to also fit a table to have a DR/LR layout. Sq ft is estimated. Does have washer/dryer hookup, spacious room size. Missing doors for cabinets on order. Unit still in progress of being renovated but will be ready by Jan 15

Beds:
3
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,808
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6288587
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
0.53 Acres
Year built:
1920
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Realty, (845) 784-6716
View additional info

Welcome to this charming rental nestled in the heart of Monticello! This cozy abode boasts 3 spacious bedrooms and 2 bathrooms, offering ample space!! Surrounded by a variety of amenities including local eateries, shopping centers, close to Catskill Mountains, Bethel Woods, Kartrite Indoor Resort & Waterpark, lakes, & parks! This is such a great rental opportunity, don't delay. Call now for your showing!!!

Beds:
2
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,000
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6302260
Type:
Apartment
Lot size:
0.83 Acres
Year built:
1952
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Century 21 Country Realty, (845) 791-5280
View additional info

Beautifully renovated 2 bedroom apt in the village of Monticello. The apt is a first floor apt and has a shared entrance with 1 tenant. Kitchen has stainless steel appliances. Property provides ample parking spaces and open grassy areas. The apt is located about 100 feet away from de hoyos memorial park. Tenant is responsible for electric bill, and propane for stove. Heat is electric hot water is electric. 1 month rent 1 month security 1/2 a month realtor fee.

Beds:
2
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
917
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6299179
Type:
Ranch, Multi-Family
Lot size:
0.53 Acres
Year built:
1925
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Exp Realty, 888-276-0630
View additional info

Modern open floor plan, 1st floor 2BR apartment. Master bedroom features room/space for an office or dressing room, Jack and Jill bathroom. Eat-In-Kitchen features brand new stainless steel appliances, new cabinets and countertops, spacious living room with picturesque window. New water heaters, new windows, laminate floors throughout Minimum income requirement is 3x the rent, 1 month security deposit plus 1st months rent, 1 month broker fee.

Beds:
4
Baths:
3.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,054
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6279019
Type:
Single Family
Lot size:
5.07 Acres
Year built:
1988
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: The Maxx Group LLC, (845) 866-4673
View additional info

Just in time for Peace, Love, and Lights, The Holiday Market at Bethel Woods, The all-new Holiday Mountain Ski & Fun Park, and so much more! Are you looking for a seasonal rental, an extended vacation, or just a fantastic place to call home and experience the beauty of the Catskills for the winter? Well, this is it. Walking distance to Bethel Woods Performing Arts and Museum and just a short drive to the Kartrite water park, The Resorts World Casino, Skiing, and much more. This newly renovated contemporary beauty has a large primary suite with a walkout deck to enjoy views of the famous Phillipini pond and a primary suite bathroom that makes you feel like you are in a top-notch spa. The bathroom features a steam shower & shower jets, plus a freestanding tub with air bath jets and a separate water closet with a washlet toilet. An open living space and entertaining area with a wall of windows and a double-sided fireplace leads to the central hub. When I say central hub, I mean the over-the-top, truly sublime kitchen with Miele appliances, a statement hood vent, custom cabinetry, integrated lighting, and a sprawling kitchen island. A huge picture window in the kitchen will become your favorite spot to cozy up with your coffee and enjoy the sunrise over the water. There are two bedrooms and two baths on the top level. Downstairs, there are two bedrooms, one with an en-suite bath. This is a fantastic opportunity to rent this home for the season and experience the best of the Catskills. Truly a breath of fresh air!

Beds:
2
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
1,000
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6300646
Type:
Multi-Family
Lot size:
0.18 Acres
Year built:
1940
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Joy Romano Realty, 845-701-9711
View additional info

Property Features: 2 Bedrooms (1 Master with En-Suite Bathroom) 2 Full Bathrooms Open Concept Living Area and Kitchen Close Proximity to Local Amenities Parking available. Trash pickup included. 1st months rent, 1 month security and 1/2 months rent broker fee due at lease signing. Must have steady income and good credit.

Beds:
1
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,919
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6296331
Type:
Other
Lot size:
0.19 Acres
Year built:
1995
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Realty, (845) 928-8000
View additional info

Room for rent! Enjoy this large room with plenty of space for you and all your belongings! Utilities are included and parking lot offers plenty of space for your vehicle. There is a small shed on the property that can also be rented ( for an additional monthly fee ). Great location, walking distance to local stores, eateries, parks and pools. Schedule your showing today!

Beds:
1
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,919
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6296512
Type:
Other
Lot size:
0.19 Acres
Year built:
1995
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Realty, (845) 928-8000
View additional info

Room for rent! Enjoy this large room with plenty of space for you and all your belongings! Utilities are included and parking lot offers plenty of space for your vehicle. There is a small shed on the property that can also be rented ( for an additional monthly fee ). Great location, walking distance to local stores, eateries, parks and pools. Schedule your showing today!

Beds:
1
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,919
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6296514
Type:
Other
Lot size:
0.19 Acres
Year built:
1995
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Realty, (845) 928-8000
View additional info

Room for rent! Enjoy this large room with plenty of space for you and all your belongings! Utilities are included and parking lot offers plenty of space for your vehicle. There is a small shed on the property that can also be rented ( for an additional monthly fee ). Great location, walking distance to local stores, eateries, parks and pools. Schedule your showing today!

Beds:
1
Baths:
2.00
Sq.Ft.:
2,919
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6296516
Type:
Other
Lot size:
0.19 Acres
Year built:
1995
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Realty, (845) 928-8000
View additional info

Showing until lease signing. Room for rent! Enjoy the simplicity of renting a room with common areas. Also offers a small sun room within the bedroom for extra space. Great location, walking distance to local stores, eateries, parks and pools. There is a small shed on the property that can also be rented ( for an additional monthly fee ). Schedule your showing today!

Beds:
n/a
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
438
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6294932
Type:
Multi-Family
Lot size:
0.19 Acres
Year built:
1900
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Keller Williams Hudson Valley, (845) 551-7816
View additional info

NEWLY RENOVATED STUDIO FOR RENT!! This apartment is on the third level and comes with a full bathroom with shower stall, kitchen with ample room to put a table and some chairs, and a large area that will be used for the bedroom and living room area. Landlord requires a 675+ credit score and income that is 3x the rent ($3,600). Landlord requires tenant to pay one month's rent, one month's security, and a rental fee equal to one month's rent ($3,600). NO PETS ALLOWED. Landlord will pay for water usage and gas (which covers gas for the stove, heat, and hot water). Tenant will be responsible for electricity. No washer and dryer in unit. Come take a look!

Beds:
2
Baths:
1.50
Sq.Ft.:
750
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6296400
Type:
Apartment
Lot size:
0.11 Acres
Year built:
1926
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Orange West Realty, (845) 856-4400
View additional info

2 BR 1.5BA, Freshly painted, Clean and Bright Apartment Located in a well maintained 4 family. 2nd floor with Eat in kitchen, Lots of closet space, Large windows that let in so much light!!! Featuring a Kitchen, Living room and half bath on one floor, 2 bedrooms and full bath located upstairs as this is a 2 floor apartment!!! Sorry no pets. Landlord requires tenant to pay a broker fee equivalent to 1 months rent as well as a 1 month security deposit, total move in cost $5,100. Credit and background checks required. Call to make your appointment today!!

Beds:
1
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
900
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6277971
Type:
Multi-Family
Lot size:
0.18 Acres
Year built:
1931
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Curasi Realty, Inc., (845) 457-9174
View additional info

Fully Available 4/24/24.....Completely renovated 1 bedroom 1 bath apartment. Very conveniently located to shopping, restaurants etc. Three miles to Route 84 for easy commuting. This rental offers a new kitchen complete with appliances, a new bath, new flooring and paint. It looks beautiful! Trash, snow and lawn care included. Off street parking in right side driveway. Great porch to enjoy. Nice big back yard.

Beds:
1
Baths:
1.00
Sq.Ft.:
750
Status:
Active
MLS#:
H6290255
Type:
Apartment
Lot size:
0.17 Acres
Year built:
1936
A broker reciprocity listing Listing by: Curasi Realty, Inc., (845) 457-9174
View additional info

Are you looking to rent a cozy renovated 1 bedroom apartment, but don't want to spend the money on furnishing it. Well, this apartment has the option of being fully furnished for you. This apartment conveniently located 10 minutes to NY,PA and NJ. There is plenty of parking spaces as well. The inside of this adorable apartment sports updated laminate flooring, custom walls and updated bath as well.

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program of OneKey MLS, Inc. The source of the displayed data is either the property owner or public record provided by non-governmental third parties. It is believed to be reliable but not guaranteed. This information is provided exclusively for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use. Per New York legal requirement, click here for the Standard Operating Procedures. Copyright {{date year}}, OneKey MLS, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

How may I help you?

Get property information, schedule a showing or find an agent






We respect your privacy